Wednesday, January 19, 2022

Could There Be Two Gods (Or Two Maximally Great Beings)?

             Could there be two Gods? This question should be addressed from a metaphysical standpoint. From the perspective of comparative religions, the term ‘God’ refers to the God of Judaism or Brahman of Hinduism or Allah of Islam or YHWH of Historic Christianity (with respect to Historic Christianity the scope of this subject does not extend to address the tri-personhood of the monotheistic God).

            God is ontologically defined as the ‘Maximally Great Being.’ A maximally great being, as Alvin Plantinga defines, should be a maximally excellent being, wherein God is omnipotent, omniscient, and morally perfect in a world, and this being would be maximally great in a world if and only if HE is maximally excellent in every possible world.1 The maximally great being is also a necessary being (not contingent), uncaused, spaceless, timeless, immaterial, changeless, personal creator of the universe.

            One question that could be asked while engaging in religious conversations with brothers/sisters of other worldviews or even within one’s own faith is whether there is a metaphysical possibility of an existence of two Gods i.e. two maximally great beings. Or is it metaphysically impossible for two maximally great beings to exist.

            First, consider a rather elementary philosophical thought process. Is it plausible to conceptualize a metaphysical or an ontic impossibility of two maximally great beings? From an ontic sense, a maximally great being can only be singular.

            There cannot be two maximally great beings because, for any given attribute or for the cumulative set of all innate attributes, only one being could be maximally great whereas all the other beings would be inferior to this maximally great being. 

            Second, philosophers have wrestled with this question and have come up with sophisticated philosophical arguments to prove God’s unicity. Unicity of God is “The attribute of God by which He is one and unique, and thus set off from the multiplicity of His creatures.”2

            If you are interested in comprehending the various arguments affirming God’s unicity, then do deep dive into the article entitled “Monotheism” in the website of Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.3 

            So to conclude, God is one (Deuteronomy 6:4; Mark 12:29). It is metaphysically impossible for the existence of two maximally great beings. So, there cannot be two Gods.


Endnotes:

1https://iep.utm.edu/ont-arg/

2https://www.encyclopedia.com/religion/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/unicity-god

3https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/monotheism/

Websites last accessed on 19th January 2022. 

Saturday, January 15, 2022

Is The King James Version (KJV) The Most Literal Translation Of The Bible?

             Some well-meaning and sincere Christians claim that the KJV is the most literal translation of the Bible. However, Daniel B. Wallace,1 an authority in the field of New Testament manuscripts, refutes this claim.

            If the KJV contains more words than any other translations of the Bible, then the claim that the KJV is the most literal version would be invalid. Dan Wallace writes:2

...the Greek New Testament has about 138,000–140,000 words, depending on which edition one is using. But no English translation has this few. Here are some examples:

RSV           173,293

NIV           175,037

ESV           175,599

NIV 2011   176,122

TNIV           176,267

NRSV          176,417

REB             176,705

NKJV           177,980

NET             178,929

RV                179,873

ASV             180,056

KJV              180,565

NASB 95      182,446

NASB           184,062

NLT, 2nd ed  186,596

TEV              192,784


It’s no surprise that the TEV and NLT have the most words, since these are both paraphrases. But the translations perceived to be more literal are often near the bottom of this list (that is, farther away from the Greek NT word-count). These include the KJV (#12), ASV (#11), NASB (#14), NASB 95 (#13), and RV (#10). Indeed, when the RV came out (1881), one of its stated goals was to be quite literal and the translators were consciously trying to be much more literal than the KJV.

In fact, Dan Wallace cites KJV’s preface, which claims that it is not exactly a literal translation, “The preface to the KJV actually claims otherwise. For example, they explicitly said that they did not translate the same word in the original the same way in the English but did attempt to capture the sense of the original each time...”

            So to conclude, the KJV’s preface and its word count lends credence to the fact that it is NOT the most literal translation of the Bible. But it is very important to note that the KJV does not impede man’s salvation in any possible manner. It is as trustworthy as the ESV, RSV, NASB, NIV et al.


Endnotes:

1Dan Wallace is the Senior Research Professor of New Testament Studies at Dallas Theological Seminary and Executive Director of the Center for the Study of New Testament Manuscripts [CSNTM].

2https://danielbwallace.com/2012/10/08/fifteen-myths-about-bible-translation/

Websites last accessed on 15th January 2022. 

Wednesday, January 12, 2022

Five Significant Biblical Archaeological Discoveries Of 2021

            Every year the Bible’s credibility/trustworthiness is further augmented by archaeological discoveries. These are five significant biblical archaeological discoveries of the year 2021:

1. Second Synagogue in Magdala (December 2021)

            A second 2000-year-old synagogue was discovered late last year. Biblical archaeologists consider it plausible that this synagogue could have been visited by the Lord Jesus!1 If so, this discovery affirms the ministry of the Lord Jesus as stated in Matthew 9:35.2

            This synagogue is located at Migdal (or its ancient name Magdala), which is also the birthplace and the hometown of Mary Magdalene.3

2. Gideon’s Jug (July 2021)

            A fragment of a pottery jug dated 1100 years before Christ was discovered in July 2021, “An ostracon (a pottery sherd with writing) bearing the name Jerubbaal, has been unearthed at Khirbat er-Ra‘I, located near the ancient city of Lachish. Jerubbaal (“Let Baal contend against him”) was the nickname that Gideon was given after he destroyed the altar of Baal (Judges 6:32). The ostracon dates to the 12th-11th century BC (ie. the time of the Judges) based on typology and radiocarbon dating from organic samples taken from the same archaeological layer in which it was found. The name Jerubbaal is only ever used for Gideon in the Bible, and this is the first discovery of it in an archaeological context.”4

            This jug need not necessarily belong to the biblical Gideon because Gideon lived 100 years prior to the dating of this jug.5 “Regardless, this discovery is significant in that it affirms the name Jerubbaal was used during the time the Bible describes.”6

3. Dead Sea Fragments (March 2021)

            Additional Dead Sea Scroll parchments were discovered for the first time in almost 60 years! These parchments included verses from Zechariah 8:16-17 and Nahum 1:5-6 written in ancient Greek. This discovery was significant because of the presence of “two interesting aspects: (1) A special treatment for the Tetragrammaton (the transliteration of the Hebrew name of God in four letters YHWH), and (2) Evidence of changing words to improve a new translation.7

4. Sandstone Inscription of the Egyptian Pharaoh Hophra (June 2021)

            “A stela naming the Egyptian Pharaoh Wahibre (known as Hophra in Hebrew, Apries in Greek) was recently found by a farmer who was cultivating his field; he immediately turned it over to the Egyptian Ministry of Tourism and Antiquities... The Bible records that King Zedekiah rebelled against the Babylonian king, Nebuchadnezzar (Ez 17:15), who had placed him on the throne (2 Kgs 24:15-17), and turned to Egypt for help. Hophra’s army marched to Zedekiah’s aid, and Nebuchadnezzar’s army withdrew from attacking Jerusalem (Jer. 37:5-8). It will be interesting to see if the recently-discovered stele of Hophra is related to this campaign. Pharaoh Hophra is mentioned by name in Jeremiah 44:30, which reads, “This is what the LORD says: ‘I am going to hand Pharaoh Hophra king of Egypt over to his enemies who seek his life, just as I handed Zedekiah king of Judah over to Nebuchadnezzar king of Babylon, the enemy who was seeking his life.’”  It should be noted that, the stela was discovered in Ismailia, Egypt, only 29 miles south of the ancient city of Taphanhes, where Jeremiah had been taken (Jer. 43:6-7) and from where he made the prophecy against Pharaoh Hophra (Jer. 44:1).”8

5. Missing Wall of Biblical Jerusalem (July 2021)

            The “Israel Antiquities Authority announced the groundbreaking discovery of the eastern section of Jerusalem’s Iron Age wall. The wall, stretching along the eastern slope of the Kidron Valley, was uncovered in the City of David Archaeological Park, a short distance from the Temple Mount. Stamps seals and other objects found along the wall allowed the excavators to date the wall to the Iron Age, indicating that it was likely part of the fortifications built by King Hezekiah (Isaiah 22:9), as he prepared for the Assyrian invasion (c. 701 B.C.E.). This also would have been the very same wall that was ultimately destroyed during the Babylonian siege of Jerusalem about a century later (2 Kings 25:10).”9  This discovery “conclusively proves that Jerusalem was strongly fortified during the time of the kings of Judah.”10


ENDNOTES:

1https://www.christianitytoday.com/news/2021/december/biblical-archaeology-top-10-discoveries-new-artifacts-2021.html

2https://biblearchaeologyreport.com/2021/12/28/top-ten-discoveries-in-biblical-archaeology-in-2021/

3https://www.timesofisrael.com/second-ancient-synagogue-found-in-migdal-alters-ideas-of-jewish-life-2000-years-ago/

4https://biblearchaeologyreport.com/2021/12/28/top-ten-discoveries-in-biblical-archaeology-in-2021/

5https://www.christianitytoday.com/news/2021/december/biblical-archaeology-top-10-discoveries-new-artifacts-2021.html

6https://biblearchaeologyreport.com/2021/12/28/top-ten-discoveries-in-biblical-archaeology-in-2021/

7https://rajkumarrichard.blogspot.com/2021/05/latest-dead-sea-scrolls-discovery-what.html

8https://biblearchaeologyreport.com/2021/12/28/top-ten-discoveries-in-biblical-archaeology-in-2021/

9https://www.biblicalarchaeology.org/daily/missing-wall-of-biblical-jerusalem-discovered/

10https://www.biblicalarchaeology.org/daily/2021s-top-ten-stories-in-bhd/

Websites last accessed on 12th January 2022.